-Discussion questions as to "Militia" and  Unconstitutional Socialized Health Care.  

Background for study question:    (updated 8/22/2009)  

In the event Nationalized Government Controlled Health Care is enacted, such act would be without constitutional authorization, as there is no enumerated power within the U.S. Constitution for such. Town hall meetings have been taking place wherein representatives ignore the people, and have even resorted to name calling - e.g., Mobs, etc... . WE THE PEOPLE realize that once enacted, government controlled health care will be extremely difficult to remove.

This clear intent to impose this Socialist / Marxist government controlled health care system violates our Constitution, our Bill of Rights, the foundational principles of our Republic, and Declaration of Independence. Such "legislated" Marxism will force Americans into being enslaved by a government bureaucracy with respect to the  most personal and critical matters bearing upon their  personal medical care and treatment, their health, and very life itself. It will further bankrupt the United States not only economically, but will serve to eviscerated the foundational fabric of our Republic. Imposing such Marxist / Socialist mandates is surely no less egregious than subjecting WE THE PEOPLE to the laws of foreign countries, or subjecting us to the judgments of foreign tribunals,  as  the unlawful mandate of subjugation is itself  foreign and repulsive to the very  foundations of our Republic. That the subject of Socialist / Marxist deprivations of our rights as American citizens bears directly upon our very health and our right to life itself, magnifies the injustice. It is hard to imagine a more invasive deprivation and invasion of personal liberty. 

The question is not to be taken lightly: --  if such a system is forced upon WE THE PEOPLE, then wouldn't such attempt at Socialist / Marxist enslavement clearly be an act of tyranny and oppression, justifying civil disobedience by the States, and We THE PEOPLE?

A question of similar import presents itself:  --  if those who pervert our Constitution continue to ignore WE THE PEOPLE and our peaceful petitions for redress of grievances in these utmost personal and God given liberties,  is it then obvious that,  as a last resort, WE THE PEOPLE, in order to defend our God given rights against the evils of tyranny and oppression, will be left with no alternative but to resort to armed resistance and defense?

Questions for Group Discussion: 

      1.  Discuss, compare and contrast the above matters with the causes of the American Revolution. What are the similarities? What are the differences?

      2.  What role, if any, should the Individual States take part in civil disobedience to the above matters?  How?

      3.  What role, if any, should Individual Americans take part in civil disobedience to the above matters? How?

      4.   In the event doctors and medical providers seek to provide medical care to patients in "violation" of the Nationalized Government Controlled Health Care system, what will Doctors and medical providers do when they are prosecuted; their licenses  threatened with revocation; and/or their offices and medical supplies and equipment seized by armed federal agents? What will American Citizens deprived of medical care and their liberty do?

      5.  What role, if any, should armed citizens, armed doctors, armed patients, armed nurses etc..., take in the above matter (not to force administration of medical care by providers, but as a defense by doctors, nurses and citizen patients against government attempts to prevent the rendering of proper health care as determined by doctors)? For example,  your mother (age 70) has been determined by government regulators to be to "old" for the required medical care and will die without treatment.  How would this role be undertaken?

      6.  If the Militia of the Several States were revitalized, what role, if any, would they / should they take? How?

NOTE: The purpose of the above questions is for educational purposes to facilitate discussion and research on matters relating to the U.S. Declaration of Independence, U.S. Constitution, and the Bill of Rights. There is NO INTENT FOR VIOLENCE, but merely to raise important questions for educational and study purposes.